PRIVACY POLICY
SITE MAP

ASEF FORUM

2nd ASEF

Summary and Report

SUMMARY RECORD OF THE ASEF ON ITS 2nd SESSION
 
                 
At the invitation of The Korea Shipbuilders’ Association (KOSHIPA), the second session of the Asian Shipbuilding Experts’ Forum for International Maritime Technical Initiative (ASEF) was held at Changwon Exhibition Convention Center (CECO), Korea from 12 to 13 November 2008.
The Forum was organized by KOSHIPA; advocated by China Association of the National Shipbuilding Industry and the Shipbuilders’ Association of Japan. Japan Ship Technology Research Association served as the secretariat of ASEF.
 
 
Changwon Exhibition Convention Center (CECO)

 

It was attended by 181 experts from 12 countries.
The details of the organizations, companies, Institutes and observers were as follows.
 
China    
  organizations:
China Association of the National Shipbuilding Industry (CANSI)
China Shipbuilding Industry Corporation (CSIC)
China State Shipbuilding Corporation (CSSC)
 
  companies:
Dalian Shipbuilding Industry Co., Ltd.
Fujian Shipbuilding Industry Group Corp.
The Guangzhou Shipyard International Co,. Ltd
Hudong Heavy Machinery Co.
Hudong Zhonghua Shipbuilding
New Century Shipyard Co.
Shanhaiguan Shipbuilding Industry
 
  institutes:
Marine Design & Research Institute
Shanghai Merchant Ship Design & Research Institute
 
 
observers:
class:
 
 LR, China
India    
 
companies:
 Larsen & Toubro Shipbuilding LTD, India
 
observers:             
class
 
 
 
Indian Register of Shipping
Indonesia
 
 
 
organizations:
IPERINDO
 
  companies:  PT. Intan Sengkukyit
Japan    
 
organizations
Japan Ship Technology Research Association (JSTRA)
JTRO (Dalian)
 
 
companies:
Imabari Shipbuilding Co., Ltd.
Kawasaki Shipbuilding Corporation
Mitsubishi Heavy Industries Ltd.
Mitsui & Co.
Oshima Shipbuilding Co., Ltd.
Sumitomo Heavy industries Marine & Engineering Co., Ltd. (SHI)
Universal Shipbuilding Corporation
 
 
institutes:
 National Maritime Research Institute (NMRI)
 
observers:
governments
 
Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism,JAPAN (MLIT)
 
 
class:
American Bureau of Shipping Pacific (ABS), Japan
LR, Japan
Korea    
 
organization:
 Korea Marine Equipment Association
The Korea Shipbuilders' Association(KOSHIPA)
Korea Coating Experts Society
 
 
companies:
Daewoo Shipbuilding &Marine Engineering Co., Ltd(DSME)
Hanjin Heavy Industries& Construction co., ltd.
Hyundai Heavy Ind. Co., Ltd. (HHI)
KACE
PANASIA CO., LTD
SALES ENGINEERING TEAM,SLS SHIPBUILDING CO., LTD
Samsung Heavy Industries Co., LTD.
Sigma Samsung Coatings Co., Ltd.
STX Shipbuilding Co.,Ltd.
TCICS Co., Ltd.
DASAN CORP. LTD.
SNC CO., LTD.
Byucksan paing & coating co. ltd.
IL SEUNG CO.,LTD
NK
 
 
institutes:
ChosunUniversity
Korea Marine Equipment Research Institute (KOMERI)
Korea Ocean Research &Development Institute (KORDI)
Korea Ship Safety Technology Authority, Maritime Safety-
ResearchCenter
P&P KOREA
University of Ulsan
KWANG SAN
SeoulNationalUniversity
Busan Development Institute
ROK Naval Academy
GNTP
 
 
observers:
governments
 
Royal Norwegian Embassy (Korea)
Korean Agency for Technology and Standards(KATS)
 
 
Owners:
 Korea Ship Owner’s Association
 
 
class:
American Bureau of Shipping (ABS), Korea
Korean Register of Shipping
Lloyd's Register Korea
Malaysia  
 
 
organization:
Association of Marine Industries of Malaysia (AMIM)
Philippines    
 
companies:
Gensan Shipyard and Machine Works, Inc.
Starhorse Shipping Lines, Inc
Singapore    
 
organization:   
Association of Singapore Marine Industries
 
  companies:
Keppel Singmarine Pte Ltd
Singapore Technologies Marine Ltd
Sembcorp Marine Technology Pte Ltd
Sri Lanka    
 
companies:
 Colombo Dockyard PLC.
Taiwan    
 
companies:
CSBC Corporation
Ming Tzong Harng Trading Co., Ltd.
Thailand    
 
observers:
governments:
 
 
Ministry of Industry
Vietnam    
 
companies:
Vietnam Shipbuilding Industry Group

 

 

 

 

The program (Discussion Items) of the 2nd ASEF is as follows:
 
I. Opening and Welcoming Address
 
Mr. Kyu-Won Park, Chairman of KOSHIPA made opening addresses.
Director General for Core Industries of Ministry of Knowledge Economy (MKE) made welcoming address.

 

Mr. Kyu-Won Park, Chairman of KOSHIPA      
    Director General for Core Industries of Ministryof
    Knowledge Economy (MKE)

  

 
 
 
 
II. Keynote Speech
Mr. Oh Kong-gyun, Chairman of Korea Register of Shipping made a key note speech titled “Our Commitment to Maritimes Safety and Protection of the Marine Environment”
 
 
Mr. Oh Kong-gyun, Chairman of Korea Register of Shipping

  

 

 

 

III. Presentations and Discussions
 
Item 1  Safety Issue 1 - IMO GBS
 
 Presentations
i) “GBS – a new IMO rule making process – How it impacts the shipbuilding industry”
Mr. Koichi Yoshida, National Maritime Research Institute(Japan)  
ii) “Pilot Panel Report of GBS Tier III Verification Process for IACS CSR”
 Mr. Man-soo Kim, Daewoo Shipbuilding & Marine Engineering (Korea)
iii) Intellectual Property Rights vs. Design Transparency
Mr. O Kitamura, Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, Ltd.(Japan)

 

Mr. Man-soo Kim (Korea) 
Discussion

 

Summary
Regarding the new IMO scheme of GBS, the report of pilot panel of GBS III verification process for MSC was informed. During discussion, some issues which would impact shipbuilding industry, such as net scantling and intellectual property right (IPR), were identified. It is also emphasized that Asian shipbuilders should their voice to IMO more strongly.

 

 

 

 

Item 2  Safety Issue 2 - IMO PSPC
 
 Presentations
i) “PSPC”
Mr. Wang Guoping, Hudong Zhonghua Shipbuilding(Group) Co., Ltd. (China)
ii) “Useful and Reliable Technology,Electric Conductivity : All Soluble Salt Ions”
Mr. Hidehisa Ashida, Oshima Shipbuilding Co., LTD.  (Japan)
iii) “Corrosion Protection for COT of Crude Oil Tankers ‘Corrosion-Resistant Steel’”
Mr. Masanori Yoshida, Japan Ship Technology Research Association (Japan)
iv) “The 1st PSPC Experience”
Mr. Yong-woon Kim, Daewoo Shipbuilding & Marine Engineering (Korea)
 
 
Mr. Hidehisa Ashida (Japan)

 

 

 

Summary
A lot of suggestions were introduced based on preparation for and appreciation of PSPC for dedicated seawater ballast tanks. The rigid method was also informed as a new salinity measurement system. In addition, Corrosion Resistant steel for COT of Crude Oil Tankers was informed as a beneficial method for shipbuilding industry. Participants shared the views that they should corporate with each other to deal with corrosion issues.

 

 

 

 

Item 3 Environment Issue 1 – Air Pollution and Ship Recycling
 
Presentations
i) “Discussion on NOx Certification Obtainment and NOx Emission Survey on Board for Marine Low Speed Diesel Engine”
Mr. Zhou Weizhong, Hudong Heavy Machinery Co., Ltd. (China)
ii) “Comments on the Proposed Attained New Ship Design COIndex”
Mr. Li Xiaoping, Marine Design & Research Institute of China(China)
iii) “Ship Recycling Convention - What does it require shipbuilders to do?”
Mr. Tasuku Hirabara, Japan Ship Technology Research Association(Japan)
 
 
                Mr. Li Xiaoping (China)

 

 

 

Summary
It was shared among participants that complying with the new regulations by the amendment of the MARPOL Annex VI was one of the urgent tasks for the shipbuilding industry. In the discussion, two methods of compiling technical documents for obtaining emission certification were introduced and analyzed in detail.
Regarding greenhouse gas emission from ships, all participants shared the views that the reduction of greenhouse gas emission from ships important and that improving ship energy efficiency is vital. Also, technical discussion on the Energy Efficiency Design Index (EEDI) at the IMO was reviewed. From the floor, it was suggested that the shipbuilding industry in Asia can contribute greatly to the IMO works on EEDI by conducting trial use of the draft Energy Efficiency Design Index guidelines developed by the IMO.
The requirements of the IMO Ship Recycling Convention were illustrated in depth. What caught the participants’ attention was how to develop inventory for existing ships. It is concerned that developing inventory for existing ships might be impossible because of lack of information. Therefore, the necessity of early preparation was emphasized and understood.

 

 

 

 

Item 4  Environment Issue 2 - Ballast Water Management Convention and Current Technology Development of Ballast Water Treatment System
  
Presentations
i) “Recent Application on Regulation for Ballast Water Treatment in Ship Design”
Mr. Lu Changrong, Shanghai Merchant Ship Design & Research Institute (China)
ii) Recent Development of Ballast Water Treatment Technologies
Mr. Ki-hoon Han, Hyundai Heavy Industries Co., LTD. (Korea)

 

Mr. Lu Changrong (China)

 

 

Summary
The regulations of the Ballast Water Management Convention and the procedures for approval of Ballast Water Treatment System (BWTS) were explained, and then the participants were informed of the current development of BWTS, including the technology for ballast water treatment. The discussion covered a number of issued with regards to BWTS, such as the difficulties of installing BWTS on ships and the effects of chemicals used in BWTS. Participants showed various interests in this topic: necessary time to complete ballast water treatment: the necessity of special training to operate BWTS.

 

 

 

 

Item 5 Any Other items
 
Presentation
i”The Development Trend of Green Shipbuilding Technology”
Mr. Hong-He Ping ,The Guangzhou Shipyard International Co,. Ltd (China)
ii)“Overview of regulations and standards on marine environment protection”
Mr. Sei-chang Lee, Korean Register of Shipping (KR)
 
 
Mr. Hong-He Ping (China)
Mr. Sei-chang Lee (Korea)

 

 

 

 
Summary
A wide range of regulations and standards on marine environment protection were discussed. The discussion referred to the Anti-Fouling Convention, which just entered into force on 17 September 2008. Furthermore, the progress of ISO on marine corrosion and fouling was informed. In addition, the results of ISO TC8/SC2 (Marine Environment Protection) held from 4 to 10 April 2008 were introduced to the participants. It was recognized that the shipbuilding industry should tackle many environmental issues simultaneously and strenuously.

 

 

 

 

Item 6   Discussion on ASEF Framework, NGO to IMO and any other items
i)“Amendment to the Resolution 1(1) of 1st ASEF [Framework of ASEF] and information on NGO s in IMO”
Mr. Tsuyoshi Yahagi, Japan Ship Technology Research Association (Japan)

Summary
The draft ASEF Framework amendment was discussed. After some modifications, the amendment was unanimously agreed and adopted as Resolution 2(1). According to the Resolution, JSTRA become the Secretariat of ASEF until the next ASEF and ASEF will explore the establishment of NGO to IMO. China’s offer for the host of the next ASEF meeting was highly welcomed among all participants.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 
ASEF 2008
EXTRA MEETING ON IMO GBS 
 
The IMO GBS is one of the most important issues for the shipbuilders, and the main topic of the ASEF 2008 accordingly. For the detail and technical discussions on this issue, an extra meeting was arranged as follows:
 
Date: Friday, November 14, 2008   
Venue: The City7 Pullman Ambassador Hotel (ORIOX hall, 2nd Floor)
Attendance: 24 experts from China, Korea and Japan.
Program outline:   
iReviews and more discussions on the ASEF presentations:
- Impacts of GBS on the shipbuilding industry
by Mr. K. Shibasaki
- Issues from the Pilot Project for Tier III by Mr. M. S. Kim
- Intellectual Property Rights vs. Design Transparency
by Mr. O. Kitamura
 
 
 
Summary
The issues on the definition of net scantling, Intellectual Property Right (IPR) and the date entering into force GBS were mainly discussed among experts of GBS. All participants reiterated that these issues make shipbuilders large influences and that they deal with these issues together in MSC85. In addition, it was emphasized on during the discussion that ASEF should obtain a NGO consultative status of IMO for Asian countries’ shipbuilders to make more voice in IMO.

 

 

ii) Presentations & discussions on additional topics:  
- Approaches to the development of the Generic GBS
by Mr. K. Yoshida
- Review of the results of EU SAFEDOR related to the GBS
by Dr. J. K. Lee
iii) Free discussion and Summary
- Possible shipbuilder’s contributions for the development of the GBS
- Possible collaborations among the Asian shipbuilder
 

 

Summary
Outline of the generic GBS, recent activities of the SLA GBS, current situation on discussion in IMO/MSC, SAFEDOR of EC, etc were introduced. In the discussion, LSA-GBS study of Japan was introduced, and it was noted that continuous activities with shipbuilding industries is necessary.
 
 
 
 
 
 
ANNEX
 
Amendment (DRAFT)
Resolution 2(1)
13th Nov, 2008
 
Establishment of ASEF
(ASEF: Asian Shipbuilding Experts’ Forum for International Maritime Technical Initiative)
 
 
I   Purpose of ASEF
The ASEF is intended to allow participants to establish clear channels of communication and to engage in dialogue concerning common matters related to international technical regulations and international standards, which can significantly affect shipbuilding industries. The ASEF is also intended to enhance mutual understanding among shipbuilding engineers throughout Asia; to express internationally relevant opinions; and ultimately to promote maritime safety and environmental conservation.
 
 
II Organization of ASEF
1        The Organizer shall convene and manage an ASEF at least once a year.
2        The Organizer shall call on a coordinator of ASEF.
3        The Organizer is responsible for selecting ASEF themes from significant international maritime technical regulations and related international standards. Each theme will be discussed by all participants after experts' presentation addressing controversial points
4        While there is no mandate to reach agreement on the themes to be discussed, the Organizer will compile the summary of the discussion.
5        At an event of each year’s ASEF meeting, the Organizer will determine the organization to serve as the ASEF Organizer for the subsequent year. Although the term of responsibility is one year, re-election will be permitted.
6        The Secretariat of ASEF shall be established in Japan Ship Technology Research Association (JSTRA) for the time being (until the next ASEF). The Secretariat of ASEF shall fully cooperate with the Organizer and shall plan for the future ASEF to submit proposals for Participants in ASEF etc. 
 
 
III Membership of ASEF
Full membership shall be granted to technical engineers and/or representatives of organizations involved in shipbuilding industries in Asia (shipbuilding, ship repairing and ship machinery manufacturing) and relevant R&D institutions. Governmental organizations and societies related to ships and ship classification may attend the ASEF as observer.
 
 
IV Budget issues, including payment of expenses
Operating expenses for each ASEF shall be the responsibility of the Organizer. Costs incurred for participation in ASEF shall be paid by each participant.
 
 
V   Future challenges
ASEF will explore the establishment of NGO with IMO-Consultative status.